Merkel shouldn’t despair over center-right’s Lower Saxony loss


Voters in Germany’s fourth-most populous state, Niedersachsen (Lower Saxony), have elected popular Hannover mayor Stephan Weil (pictured above) its new minister-president after an incredibly narrow victory for the center-left coalition, according to official provisional results.
lower_saxonyGermany Flag Icon

The predicted victory would mean that the center-right coalition headed by minister-president David McAllister, a high-profile (and half-Scottish!) politician within the ruling Christlich Demokratische Union (Christian Democratic Union) of German chancellor Angela Merkel would lose power for the first time in a decade.

As such, the German media is already reporting that the election is a setback for Merkel in advance of expected federal elections later in September or October 2013.  While the election is somewhat of a barometer for federal politics, generally (it’s where former chancellor Gerhard Schröder got his political start — he served as the state’s minister-president from 1990 to 1998), there’s actually a lot of positive news for Merkel in the Lower Saxony result.

Provisional results give the center-right CDU around 36.0% of the vote, a small lead over the center-left Sozialdemokratische Partei Deutschlands (SPD, the Social Democratic Party), with just 32.9%.  Unfortunately, however, that represents around a 6.5% drop in support from the previous regional elections in 2008:


Although the CDU’s traditional coalition partner, the Freie Demokratische Partei (FDP, Free Democrats), will have increased their share of the vote to around 9.9% (despite polls showing the FDP with support running at around 5%), the SPD’s traditional coalition partner, Die Grünen (the Green Party), has won around 13.5%.

According to projections, that means the CDU will hold 54 seats in the Landtag, Lower Saxony’s regional unicameral parliament (a 14-seat drop from the current representation) and the FDP will gain a seat for a total of 14.

The SPD will gain just one seat to hold 49, while the Greens have gained eight seats to hold 20.

Together, therefore, the center-left is likely to hold 69 seats to just 68 seats for the center-right, giving Weil the narrowest of margins in the Landtag

The key factor is the loss of all 11 seats currently held by the more radical Die Linke (The Left Party), which is projected to have won just 3.1% of the vote, lower than the 5% required to win seats under Lower Saxony’s electoral system.  That means that all of the center-left seats won in Sunday’s election will have gone to the SPD-Green coalition, rather than split with the Left Party, which has historically rejected the possibility of joining a coalition with the SPD.

The Piratenpartei Deutschland (Pirate Party) also fell far below the 5% threshold.

So the result is quite a setback for McAllister, who was contesting his first election as minister-president, and has been mentioned as a potential successor to Merkel as a federal chancellor.  There’s a fair chance that Merkel could bring McAllister into her federal government as a top aide and minister (she once attempted to appoint him as the head of the CDU federally).

Although McAllister isn’t incredibly unpopular in Lower Saxony, he became minister-president in 2010 after Christian Wulff, premier since 2003, resigned to assume Germany’s largely ceremonial presidency — Wulff resigned in February 2012, however, amid allegations that he concealed a private loan from a wealthy friend with business interests in Lower Saxony.

Given the scandal around Wulff, the fact that the CDU has held power for a decade and was seeking its third consecutive mandate for forming a government, and the fact that Germany is slipping into recession, McAllister was always going to have a tougher run in this year’s elections than Wulff had in 2008.

But, as I noted above, there’s a lot of good news for Merkel in advance of this autumn’s elections:

The CDU still defeated the SPD in pure number of votes. First, it’s worth noting that the CDU still won by at least 3% over the SPD in terms of the plurality vote.  Currently, the CDU, federally, is polling much higher than the CDU in Lower Saxony was polling in advance of Sunday’s election (polls show the CDU with 43% to just 25% for the SPD).  A lot can happen between now and September, obviously, but if the CDU outpolls the SPD in this autumn’s federal election, Merkel will almost certainly return as chancellor, even if she has to resort to a ‘grand coalition’ between the CDU and the SPD, which governed Germany from 2005 to 2009.

The FDP’s resurgence, if repeated federally, would give Merkel her preferred coalition.  After polls showed that the FDP would struggle to break the 5% threshold for representation in the Landtag, their surprisingly strong 10% share not only massively exceeded expectations, but exceeded their 2008 share as well.  It’s very good news for the federal leader of the FDP since May 2011, Philipp Rösler, the Vietnamese-German vice chancellor and minister of the economy and technology.  Rösler, who’s from Lower Saxony, would have been under incredible pressure to resign as leader after Sunday’s election if the FDP had lost all of their seats in Lower Saxony.  If the FDP does nearly as well in federal elections, it seems likely that Merkel will be able to continue to coalition with her preferred partners, the FDP.  Unlike in Lower Saxony, there’s a possibility that the Greens could join a federal coalition with the CDU and the FDP (often referred to a ‘Jamaica’ coalition in German politics — with the green, CDU black and FDP yellow colors of the Jamaican flag).  Although Germany’s never seen a federal ‘Jamaica’ coalition, such a coalition currently governs Saarland.

Peer Steinbrück isn’t as popular as Stephan Weil.  Steinbrück, the SPD’s candidate for chancellor, served previously as the finance minister in the Merkel-led government during the ‘grand coalition’ years, so he’s had some difficulty in drawing a contrast with Merkel.  Furthermore, given that the SPD is even more pro-Europe than the CDU, it’s unlikely that Steinbrück will be willing to run a populist anti-bailout campaign against Merkel.  Since becoming the SPD’s candidate for chancellor in September 2012, Steinbrück has been criticized for making several high-profile gaffes.  In contrast, Weil has served as the popular mayor of Hanover, Lower Saxony’s largest city, since 2006, and his wife, Rosemarie Kerkow-Weil, is well-known as the president of the University of Hanover.

The CDU will be able to count on The Left to split votes in the federal election.  Although there’s also a 5% threshold for representation to the Bundestag, the lower house of the German parliament, polls for the federal election show that The Left would win 7%, just enough to win seats.  That means that the leftist vote will be fragmented, to the detriment of the SPD, and even more so if the Pirate Party (currently polling, at the federal level, just within the 5% level) manages to enter the Bundestag as well.

3 thoughts on “Merkel shouldn’t despair over center-right’s Lower Saxony loss”

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *