Bersani leads as Italian ‘centrosinistra’ primary heads to Sunday runoff

After last weekend’s first round of the primaries to choose the Italian center-left (‘centrosinistra‘) candidate for prime minister in advance of expected national elections in April, the current leader of Italy’s largest center-left party, the Partito Democratico (PD, Democratic Party), Pier Luigi Bersani looks like a favorite — even if just slightly — to win the runoff this Sunday.

Bersani (pictured above) won 44.9% of last weekend’s primary vote of around 3 million Italian voters, while the youthful mayor of Florence, Matteo Renzi, placed a close second with 35.5%.  The two faced off in a television debate earlier Wednesday, although the two candidate disagree more on tactics and broad themes than individual policies.

The regional president of Puglia — Italy’s southeastern corner — Nichy Vendola, who is openly gay and the most leftist of the three candidates, as well as the founder and leader of the more radical Sinistra Ecologia Libertà (SEL, Left Ecology Freedom), placed third with 15.6% — the SEL and a handful of other small parties have agreed to unite behind the winner of the centrosinistra primary as the prime ministerial candidate of the broad Italian left.

So with the centrosinistra primary set to end with the December 2 runoff between Bersani and Renzi, it appears that Bersani will win, despite the momentum behind Renzi’s candidacy and his promise to bring a new generation of leadership to Italy.  Vendola, earlier today, endorsed Bersani after indicating earlier that Bersani’s words were more ‘profumare di sinistra‘ — perfumed with leftism — than Renzi’s.

The battle between Renzi and Bersani is less ideological than generational — at 61, Bersani personifies the boring and staid leadership of the past 20 years of the Italian left.  At age 37, however, Renzi is something quite new in Italian politics.  His campaign’s theme is essentially that Italy is in need of a new generation of leadership — namely, Renzi’s, on the basis that a Renzi premiership would open a new and more productive era in Italian governance.  He’s not only called for an end to the era of former prime minister Silvio Berlusconi, but for a clean sweep of the Italian left as well.  Renzi’s even picked a fight with Sergio Marchionne, the CEO of Italian carmaker Fiat.

Both Renzi and Bersani have pledged to continue the era of budget discipline enacted by Italy’s current ‘technocratic’ prime minister Mario Monti, who took office in December 2011.

Monti has consistently refused to run for prime minister in his own right in the upcoming elections.  Monti, however, has indicated that he would be available to serve as technocratic prime minister again in the event of a hung parliament, and business leaders overwhelmingly favor a second Monti government to see through the budget cuts, labor reforms and tax increases that have brought Italy back from the brink of financial crisis.

Both candidates, too, have pledged to pursue more growth-oriented policies, even though it remains unclear exactly what either candidate could actually accomplish in an era of austerity throughout much of Europe.

That doesn’t mean there aren’t ideological differences between the two.

Bersani, with greater ties to Italy’s largest union, the Confederazione Generale Italiana del Lavoro (CGIL, General Confederation of Labour), comes from a stronger social democratic tradition than Renzi, who has styled himself as a modernizer not unlike former UK prime minister Tony Blair.  Bersani, the son of a mechanic, served as regional president of the leftist region of Emilia-Romagna in central Italy in the 1990s and as minister of economic development under former prime minister Romano Prodi from 2006 to 2008, where he tried to liberalize the Italian labor market.

Renzi, however, has refused to consider a potential governing coalition with the Unione di Centro (UdC, Union of the Centre), a small centrist group led by Pier Ferdinando Casini.  The UdC essentially represents the remnants of the long-dominant Italian Christian Democrats and, while Casini and the UdC would likely find overlapping interests on economic policy, the UdC, with its ties to the Vatican, remains socially conservative (e.g., it opposes same-sex marriage).  Bersani, although he is seen as slightly more leftist than Renzi, has nonetheless remained open to a coalition with Casini’s centrists.

Ultimately, it’s hard for me to believe that Renzi will actually win on December 2.  The ‘primary’ itself seems skewed in Bersani’s favor — he’s already the leader of the PD, has the support of much of the ‘old guard’ of the Italian left (such as former prime minister and foreign minister Massimo D’Alema), and accordingly, he has access to the left’s strongest party machinery, not to mention the benefit of his CGIL ties.  He now apparently has Vendola’s support from the SEL as well.

Furthermore, in a country that shows perhaps more respect for its elders than anywhere else in Europe, it seems unlikely that Italy will anoint as a potential prime minister someone so incredibly young.  The contest is especially meaningful because the PD looks set to win the upcoming elections (although the contest remains exceptionally fluid and unpredictable, even by the sometime operatic standards of Italian politics).

The latest EMG poll shows the PD with 30.3% of the vote, compared to 17.3 for the Movimento 5 Stelle (M5S, the Five Star Movement), a protest vehicle organized by comedian and blogger Beppe Grillo.  Think of him as Italy’s more self-righteous version of Jon Stewart.  The M5S recently won the highest share of an incredibly fragmented vote in Sicily’s regional elections on Oct. 30, though it remains unclear what the M5S stands for other than opposition to politics as usual.

Berlusconi’s center-right Popolo della Libertà (PdL, People of Freedom) wins just 16.4%, amid even more uncertainty about the Italian right’s standard-bearer.  After leaving office last November amid a financial crisis, corruption allegations and sex scandal, Berlusconi hinted last weekend that he’ll return to front-line politics (that comes after, in the past two months alone, Berlusconi bowed out of politics, hinted he could return, bowed out again and was convicted for tax fraud).  Berlusconi hinted, too, that he might step aside for Renzi, indicating that Renzi’s youthful energy could bring about a robust social democratic party in Italy.  Berlusconi has also hinted he might just start a new party.  In any event, the PdL had been scheduled to hold its own primary elections on December 16, but that is now unclear, pending Berlusconi’s latest decision.

PdL secretary Angelino Alfano, a former justice secretary in Berlusconi’s government, is seen as the frontrunner to lead the Italian right in 2013 elections, provided that Berlusconi doesn’t run, although Rome’s mayor Gianni Alemanno, a strident social conservative and former fascist, could also emerge as a standard-bearer.

A group of smaller parties trailed the three major groups:

  • the autonomist, northern and conservative Lega Nord (LN, Northern League), which has boosted Berlusconi’s governments in the past, would win 6.8%;
  • Vendola’s SEL wins 6.1%, although it would join with the PD in any governing coalition;
  • Casini’s UdC wins 4.0%;
  • the recently scandal-plagued Italia dei Valori (IdV, Italy of Values), ironically itself an anti-corruption party led by former prosecutor Antonio di Pietro, wins 2.1% (and would also join in any PD-led coalition);
  • the Federazione della Sinistra, the latest iteration of Italy’s communists, would win 2.4% (and has not agreed to join a PD-led coalition);  and
  • the center-right Futuro e Libertà per l’Italia (FLI, Future and Freedom) wins 2.0% — it’s the party of Gianfranco Fini, former Berlusconi ally, former foreign minister and former president of Italy’s lower house, the Chamber of Deputies (Camera die Deputati).

One thought on “Bersani leads as Italian ‘centrosinistra’ primary heads to Sunday runoff”

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *