Suffragio

Search
Skip to content
  • 17 Elections to Watch in 2017
  • 2017 Calendar
  • About Me
  • In Depth: Brazil
  • In Depth: Canada
  • In Depth: India
  • In Depth: UK Votes
  • U.S. Foreign Policy

Daily Archives: January 17, 2014

United States

A few quick thoughts on Obama’s NSA reform speech

January 17, 2014 Kevin Lees 1 Comment
Tweet

NSA

US president Barack Obama outlined several reform proposals for the National Security Administration’s intelligence-gathering earlier today at a speech at the Justice Department.USflag

The reforms aren’t exactly breathtaking, but Brian Fong at Wonkblog has a great primer on what they entail:

  • The secret Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Court will have to sign off to NSA requests to ‘query’ the phone metadata database.
  • When the NSA is authorized to query the database, they can only examine data for the express number and any number connected to the express number — ‘two hops,’ as opposed to the ‘three-hops’ approach that is currently the NSA standard.
  • The actually database may be entrusted in the hands of a third-party, non-governmental watchdog, though the details are far from clear.
  • The US government will stop spying on ‘dozens’ of foreign leaders.
  • John Podesta, a longtime figure in Democratic administrations, will lead a comprehensive review of big data and privacy.

It’s fairly easy to poke holes in these reforms — to the extent that they are even fully carried out.  As of June 2013, the FISC has rejected just 11 out of 33,900 surveillance requests since its creation in 1979.  That’s a 99.97% success rate for the government, which hardly constitutes a meaningful check.  Moreover, as this interactive feature from The Guardian shows, cutting back from the ‘three-hop’ approach to the ‘two-hop’ approach is meaningful, but with such a compliant judicial check, there’s nothing stopping an NSA employee from going back to the FISC for further authority. (By the way, when did US intelligence policy start taking its cues from a marginal 1990s Kevin Bacon film?)

It’s even more skeptical whether the NSA database will be transferred to a truly independent third party.  Of course, the US government will certainly continue to spy on world leaders, even if it backs away from spying on the leaders of its top allies.  Podesta, a former Clinton chief of staff, co-chair of the Obama transition team and chair of the Center for American Progress, a top progressive think tank in Washington DC, seems unlikely to rock the boat.

Moreover, the Obama administration has a relatively small well of goodwill on the issue.  It’s been eight months since Obama, in another major speech on drone strikes, promised to limit drone strikes and to minimize casualties, pledging also greater transparency.  But the drone strikes policy remains shrouded in mystery today, and it’s unclear where the ‘covert’ operations of the Central Intelligence Agency end and the ‘clandestine’ operations of the US military, especially the Joint Special Operations Command begin.  Just before Christmas, the US government killed 15 civilians in an attack on what turned out to be a Yemeni wedding party, drawing massive rebuke both inside Yemen and beyond.  There’s not a whole lot of evidence that the Obama administration has seriously reformed its drone strikes policies. 

So while a fancy speech on NSA reform is great, there’s absolutely no evidence that the Obama administration really takes intelligence reform seriously.  Though Obama’s speech was couched in the same constitutional-professor-in-chief tone as the drone speech, he blamed virtually everyone except his own administration for having to address the NSA mission creep that’s occurred on his watch: Continue reading A few quick thoughts on Obama’s NSA reform speech →

Share this:

  • Share
  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • Print
  • Email
  • Reddit
databasedroneFISAFISCmerkelmetadatanational securityNSAobamaPatriot ActpodestarousseffsnowmenstasisurveillanceUnited States

Support Suffragio


(Currency: USD)

About Suffragio

Suffragio attempts to bring thoughtful analysis to the political, economic and other policy issues that are central to countries outside of the US -- to make world politics less foreign to the US audience. Suffragio focuses, in particular, on those countries and regions with upcoming or recent elections.

Choose a country:

Twitter

Kevin Lees
  • RT @Simplified_US: William Jennings Bryan Runs For President (1896, 1900, 1908) https://t.co/FPIpqTLIlr 03:26:02 PM July 10, 2023 from Twitter for Android
  • RT @karpi: I've asked an AI to generate a trailer for a HEIDI movie and now I can never sleep again https://t.co/8M9t726hrI 01:51:18 PM July 10, 2023 from Twitter for Android
  • I think this is basically how Ukraine joins NATO. It would weaken (to some degree) Article 5 (avoiding a worst-case… https://t.co/I9S7BfeitY 11:43:33 AM July 10, 2023 from Twitter for Android
  • 1. Admit Ukraine ASAP to NATO. 2. Make clear that nothing changes from what we're currently doing to bolster Ukrain… https://t.co/rpUWiM7qWh 11:41:34 AM July 10, 2023 from Twitter for Android
  • This is epic and alone worth the price of @mattyglesias stack. One thing I'd add is the pandemic playbook we had w… https://t.co/RvQD2waBRc 11:37:27 AM July 10, 2023 from Twitter for Android
  • You can't be this successful and not competitive. This shouldn't be hard. https://t.co/tpjomJ1hCd 11:16:05 PM July 09, 2023 from Twitter for Android
  • RT @GoldenGirls2085: Dorothy Zbornak arrives at the #Barbie premiere. https://t.co/kLrxSIk9Yq 11:09:17 PM July 09, 2023 from Twitter for Android
  • Lol the world takes a breath https://t.co/VIGhaV9Wu7 10:58:50 PM July 09, 2023 from Twitter for Android
  • Was at a friend date-ish thing tonight and the old dude from Europe started mocking fat, toothless Americans, and I… https://t.co/qFApRuRmmK 10:03:51 PM July 09, 2023 from Twitter for Android
  • RT @emilynussbaum: It’s gross to post your ex’s private texts unless you have a really solid reason to do so—& this holds true even if your… 06:20:10 PM July 09, 2023 from Twitter for Android
  • I simply don't believe this. https://t.co/yB6UtnMYXM 02:30:12 PM July 09, 2023 from Twitter for Android
@suffragio

Tags

assad austerity berlusconi Cameron canada CDU chavez china coalition Congress conservative democratic party egypt European Union France germany greece Hollande india iran israel Italy labor labour liberal liberal party marine le pen merkel modi obama PD PS putin republican russia Sarkozy social democrats syria syriza tory trump tsipras United Kingdom United States venezuela
January 2014
M T W T F S S
 12345
6789101112
13141516171819
20212223242526
2728293031  
« Dec   Feb »

Like Suffragio on Facebook

Like Suffragio on Facebook

MAKING WORLD POLITICS LESS FOREIGN

Poll

Who is the most impressive foreign policy / security official (so far) in the Trump administration?

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...

Blogroll

  • A Fistful of Euros
  • ABC Color (Paraguay)
  • Addis Standard
  • Africa is a Country
  • Africa Report
  • Aftenposten (Norway)
  • Al Jazeera English
  • Al-Ahram (Egypt)
  • Al-Monitor
  • Alberto Nardelli (Italy/EU)
  • allAfrica
  • América Economía
  • Americas Quarterly
  • An Arab Citizen (Bassem Sabry)
  • Analects (Economist on China)
  • Andrew Sullivan — The Daily Beast (US/UK policy)
  • Animal Politico (MX)
  • Armenia Now
  • Arms Control Wonk
  • Asahi Shimbun (Japan)
  • Asia Times
  • Athens News
  • Atlantic Community
  • B92 (Serbia)
  • Babalú Blog (Cuba)
  • Balkan Insight
  • Bangkok Post
  • Banyan (Economist on Asia)
  • Baobab (Economist on Africa)
  • BBC News
  • BDNews24 (Bangladesh)
  • Belfast Telegraph
  • Berlingske (Denmark)
  • Brazil Portal
  • Brookings Institution
  • Buenos Aires Herald
  • BusinessWorld (Philippines)
  • Calgary Herald
  • Caracas Chronicles
  • Caribbean Elections
  • Caribbean Journal
  • Charlemagne (Economist on Europe)
  • Charter97 (Belarus)
  • Chatham House
  • China Daily (US version)
  • China Times
  • ChinaFile
  • Chosun Ilbo (SK)
  • Civil (Georgia)
  • Clarín (Argentina)
  • Colombia Reports
  • Copenhagen Post
  • Corriere della Sera (IT)
  • Council on Foreign Relations Blogs
  • Cyprus Mail
  • Dagens Nyheter (Sweden)
  • Daily Graphic (Ghana)
  • Daily Inquirer (Phiippines)
  • Daily Maverick (South Africa)
  • Daily Monitor (Uganda)
  • Daily Nation (Kenya)
  • Daily Star (Bangladesh)
  • Daily Star (Lebanon)
  • Daily Telegraph (Australia)
  • Daily Telegraph (UK)
  • Daniel Berhane (Ethiopia)
  • Daniel Drezner (Foreign Policy)
  • Dawn (Pakistan)
  • De Standaard (Flemish)
  • Der Spiegel (International)
  • Der Standard (Austria)
  • Diário de Notícias (Portugal)
  • Die Presse (Austria)
  • Die Welt (Germany)
  • Duck of Minerva
  • Dutch News (English)
  • DW (Germany)
  • E Kathimerini
  • East Asia Forum
  • EG Justice (Equatorial Guinea)
  • Egypt Independent
  • El Comercio (Peru)
  • El Heraldo (Honduras)
  • El Khabar (Algeria)
  • El Mundo (Spain)
  • El Nacional (Venezuela)
  • El Nuevo Dîa (Puerto Rico)
  • El País (Spain)
  • El Siglo (Panamá)
  • El Tiempo (Colombia)
  • El Universal (MX)
  • El Universal (VZ)
  • Electionista
  • Electoral Geography
  • EU Observer
  • EurActiv
  • Europolitics
  • Excélsior
  • Felix Salmon — Reuters (Economics/Finance)
  • FirstPost (India)
  • Folha (São Paolo)
  • Foreign Policy
  • Foreign Policy Association Blogs
  • France24
  • Francis Fukuyama (American Interest)
  • Frankfurter Allgemeine Zeitung
  • Fréttablaðið (Iceland)
  • FT Alphaville
  • Generación Y (Cuba — Yoani Sánchez)
  • Giornale di Sicilia
  • Global Post
  • Globe and Mail
  • Granma (Cuba)
  • Guardian
  • Guardian (Nigeria)
  • Gulf News (UAE)
  • Haaretz (Israel)
  • Helsinki Times
  • Hindustan Times
  • Honduras Culture and Politics
  • Hoy (Dominican Republic)
  • Hoy (Ecaudor)
  • http://www.voanews.com
  • http://www.zeit.de/index
  • Hürriyet (Turkey)
  • Iceland Review
  • IFES
  • Il Sole 24 Ore (Italy)
  • Info Matin (Mali)
  • Informed Consent (Juan Cole)
  • Inside Greece
  • International IDEA
  • Irish Independent
  • Irish Times
  • Italy Chronicles
  • Jakarta Globe
  • Jakarta Post
  • James Fallows (The Atlantic)
  • Japan Times
  • Jeffrey Goldberg (The Atlantic)
  • Jerusalem Post
  • Jeune Afrique
  • Jordan Times
  • Journal of Democracy (JHU)
  • Khaleej (Dubai)
  • Korea Herald
  • Korea Times
  • Kyiv Post
  • L'Avenir (Congo)
  • L'Essor (Mali)
  • L'Express de Madagascar
  • La Liberte (Algeria)
  • La Libre Belgique
  • La Nacion (Argentina)
  • La Prensa (Panamá)
  • La Presse (QC)
  • La Repubblica (IT)
  • La Tercera (Chile)
  • La Vanguardia (Catalonia)
  • LatIntelligence
  • Lawfare (Brookings)
  • Le Figaro
  • Le Matin (Morocco)
  • Le Monde
  • Libération
  • LiveMint (India)
  • LSM (Latvia)
  • Mainichi Shimbun (Japan)
  • Malay Mail
  • Malta Today
  • Manila Bulletin
  • MercoPress
  • Mmegi (Botswana)
  • Monkey Cage
  • Montreal Gazette
  • Morgenavisen Jyllands-Posten (Denmark)
  • National Interest
  • Neue Zürcher Zeitung (Swiss)
  • New Mandala (Australia-based Asia coverage)
  • New Straits Times (Malaysia)
  • New Times (Rwanda)
  • New Zealand Herald
  • NightWatch
  • Nine O'Clock (Romanian)
  • Norway Post
  • Novaya Gazeta
  • NRC Handelsblad (NL)
  • O Dia (Rio de Janeiro)
  • O Globo (Rio)
  • Obscure Suddha (Jacob Bathanti)
  • Open Europe
  • openDemocracy
  • Organization for Security and Cooperation in Europe
  • Ottomans and Zionists
  • Paul Krugman (Economics/Finance)
  • People's Daily (China)
  • Phnom Penh Post
  • Policy Network
  • Political Violence @ a Glance
  • Politiken (Denmark)
  • Prague Monitor
  • Press TV (Iran)
  • Radio Free Europe / Radio Liberty
  • Radio Prague (English)
  • Rebel Economy
  • Reforma (Mexico)
  • Rhyming with Oranges (Jazza John)
  • RIA Novosti (RU)
  • RTE News (IE)
  • Santiago Times
  • Scenari Politici (Italy)
  • Scotsman (Edinburgh)
  • Scroll'in (India)
  • Shanghaiist
  • Shisaku Blog (Japan)
  • Siempre! (Mexico)
  • Smoke & Stir (Taylor Marvin)
  • South China Morning Post (HK)
  • Standard (Kenya)
  • Straits Times (Singapore)
  • Stratfor
  • Sud Quotidien (SN)
  • Süddeutsche Zeitung (Bavaria)
  • Svenska Dagbladet (Sweden)
  • Sydney Morning Herald
  • Taipei Times
  • Tehran Times
  • Telegraaf (NL)
  • Thai Rath
  • The 545 (India)
  • The Arabist
  • The Australian
  • The Bhutanese
  • The Cable (FP)
  • The Devil's Excrement (Venezuela)
  • The Diplomat
  • The Disorder of Things
  • The Economist
  • The Hankyoreh (SK)
  • The Hindu
  • The Independent (South Africa)
  • The Irrawaddy (Burma)
  • The Local (Germany)
  • The Local (Swiss)
  • The Nation (Pakistan)
  • The Reporter (Ethiopia)
  • The Standard (HK)
  • The Star (South Africa)
  • Three Hundred Eight (CA)
  • Times of India
  • Times of Malta
  • Times of Zambia
  • To Pontiki (Gr)
  • Toronto Star
  • Tripoli Post
  • Tyler Cowen and Alex Tabarrok — Marginal Revolution (economics)
  • UN Dispatch
  • Vancouver Sun
  • Venezuela News and Views
  • Vienna Review
  • Whispers in the Loggia (Vatican)
  • Wikileaks
  • Wilson Center: Mexico Institute
  • World Elections Blog
  • World Politics Review
  • Wyborcza (Poland)
  • Xinhua (China)
  • Y-Net (Israel)
  • Yemen Times
  • Yomiuri Shimbun (Japan)
  • Zaman (Turkey)
  • Коммерсантъ (Kommersant, Russia)
Proudly powered by WordPress