Bob Rae, the interim leader of the beleaguered Liberal Party in Canada and one-time premier of Ontario, will not seek the Liberal Party’s leadership.
It is an unexpected announcement — Rae had received better marks for his performance as interim leader than his predecessors Michael Ignatieff (who defeated Rae in 2009 for the leadership) and Stéphane Dion (who defeated Rae in 2006), and was seen to be the frontrunner in the race.
The 40-year-old Trudeau has represented Papineau, a Montreal district, since 2008. Trudeau had previously ruled out a run at the leadership, but pressure is already mounting on Trudeau as the last hope for the once-great party of Canada’s center-left — and he is already ‘listening’ to that pressure in the wake of Rae’s decision.
Even as the party gears up for the leadership contest expected in early 2013, polls show the Conservative Party and the New Democratic Party currently tied for the lead in national polls, with the Liberals still trailing far behind — ThreeHundredEight‘s May 2012 federal poll average showed the NDP with 35%, the Tories with 34% and the Liberals with just 19%.
Rae’s strong performance since 2011 as interim leader had made him a frontrunner alongside Trudeau for the permanent leadership. Indeed, he’s seen as a stronger adversary for Harper than even the official opposition leader — Quebec MP Thomas Mulcair, who was elected as the NDP’s new leader only in March 2012.
But a full-fledged Rae leadership candidacy would have been problematic on several levels:
- In stepping down as interim leader to run in his own right, Rae would have destabilized the Liberals in Parliament at a time when the party can least afford it, with Mulcair now consolidating his position as opposition leader.
- His interim leadership has not done anything to help the Liberals’ poll numbers, which remain as low as the party’s depressed support in the 2011 general election.
- It is unclear that Rae, a twice-failed leadership candidate in his mid-60s, would be able to lead the party through the two or three election cycles that it is likely to take for the party to move up from 34 seats to Official Opposition and then back into government.
- A leadership campaign would have undoubtedly dredged up his controversial record as the NDP premier of Ontario in the 1990s (he failed to win reelection in 1995), and it would also have subjected him to suspicions that he’s keen on engineering a merger with the NDP (which, for what it’s worth, might not be the worst idea for the Liberal Party).
All things considered, his decision seems sound, and it allows Rae to play the elder statesman in the near future as a new generation of Liberals emerge — a generation that seems to begin and end with Trudeau, but includes nearly a dozen of potential leaders:
- Dalton McGuinty, premier of Ontario since 2003 who, like Trudeau, had previously ruled out a leadership run.
- David McGuinty, Dalton’s brother, an Ontario MP since 2004 and the party’s parliamentary natural resources critic.
- Dominic LeBlanc, a New Brunswick MP since 2000, briefly a leadership candidate in 2008, and currently the party’s foreign affairs critic.
- Scott Brison, a Nova Scotia MP since 2000 who crossed the aisle from the Progressive Conservatives in 2003 — Brison is openly gay, served as Minister of of Public Works and Government Services under Paul Martin from 2004 to 2006, contested the Liberal leadership in 2006, and currently serves as the party’s finance critic.
- Robert Ghiz, the premier of Prince Edward Island since 2007.
- Ken Dryden, a former hockey start who served as an MP from 2000 to 2011 from Toronto, and who also contested the 2006 leadership race.
- Marc Garneau, a retired astronaut and former president of the Canadian Space Agency from 2001 to 2006, who has served as an MP since 2008 from Montreal and is the current Liberal House Leader.
- Mark Carney, governor of the Bank of Canada since 2008.
- Gerard Kennedy, an Ontario MP from 2008 to 2001 and Ontario’s minister of education from 2003 to 2006 — he finished a respectable fourth in the 2006 Liberal leadership race, behind Ignatieff, Rae and Dion.
The Liberal Party governed the country for nearly 70 years in the 20th century, but is today very much in trouble:
- After holding power for over a decade under Jean Chrétien and Paul Martin, the Liberals started losing ground to Stephen Harper’s newly consolidated and insurgent Conservative Party in the 2004 general election, winning just 135 seats and 37% of the vote to 99 seats for the Tories.
- In the 2006 general election, Harper won his first minority government, while the Liberals held just 103 seats on a vote of 30%.
- Under Dion, in the 2008 general election, the party lost 18 seats (down to 77) in the House of Commons on a vote of 26%.
- The bottom fell out in the 2011 election under Ignatieff, when the Grits won 34 seats on a vote of just under 19%, ceding the Official Opposition status to the late Jack Layton’s NDP.